Nested forcing net

Difficulty Impossible

A nested forcing net compares several possibilities inside one branch of a larger proof. An inner contradiction rules out a choice in that branch. It rules out the outer assumption only if every way to continue the branch fails.

Branch where the outer trial still has a choice

Begin with an outer assumption. If direct moves stop, choose a cell or house with few choices inside that branch. Try all the inner choices separately. Carry a conclusion back to the outer branch only if every surviving inner choice supports it.

An inner proof tells you what follows from the outer assumption. To make a move on the original grid, finish the outer proof as well.

Examples

Example 1

Example 1 ready.

Keep the outer assumption in view while you follow the inner branches. Compare their results before continuing the outer case.

The two inner cases are “5 goes in R1C6” and “5 is ruled out in R1C6.” Both lead to a conflict, so the starting assumption is impossible.

Remove 1 from R5C4.

Read the proof step by step

Suppose 1 goes in R5C4.

  1. 2 is ruled out in R5C4 (from the assumption).
  2. 4 is ruled out in R5C4 (from the assumption).
  3. 5 is ruled out in R5C4 (from the assumption).
  4. 8 is ruled out in R5C4 (from the assumption).
  5. 1 is ruled out in R5C1 (from the assumption).
  6. 1 is ruled out in R5C2 (from the assumption).
  7. 1 goes in R4C2 (from step 5 and step 6).
  8. 2 is ruled out in R4C2 (from step 7).
  9. 4 is ruled out in R4C2 (from step 7).

The two inner cases are “5 goes in R1C6” and “5 is ruled out in R1C6.” Both lead to a conflict, so the starting assumption is impossible.

Trainer

Difficulty Impossible

Walkthrough

Place one digit or remove one candidate.

See also