Assumptions and contradictions

Difficulty Extreme foundation

An assumption lets you examine what a candidate would force. A contradiction rules out that starting choice. A move that follows from every possible choice also holds on the original grid.

Follow one assumption on a trial grid

Choose one candidate. Suppose it is true or false. Keep the moves that follow under that assumption separate from the moves on your grid.

A contradiction must break a rule

An assumption fails if it leaves a cell empty of candidates or a house with no place for a required digit. It also fails if it forces conflicting placements. A pause in the solve proves nothing about the assumption.

A trial that puts two 2s in column 1

1 / 5

The four cells show all their candidates. Keep the trial moves separate from the original grid.

Pick the candidate to test

Can R1C1 be 2? The other three cells each have just two choices.

A blue ring marks a candidate in the pattern.A dashed line is a weak link. At most one end is true.An arrow points from an assumption to what follows.A red strike marks a candidate to remove.A green ring marks a digit to place.
Two ways to finish a forcing proof
MethodWhat you must establish
ContradictionIf A breaks a Sudoku rule, A is false.
Common resultEvery possible case leads to the same placement or removal.

Keep separate cases separate

If a cell allows {2, 5, 8}, examine all three cases before using a shared result. Never combine a removal from the 2 case with one from the 5 case.

Several moves within the same case can work together. A proof that combines them is called a forcing net.

Check your understanding

1 of 3
You try an assumption and cannot find another move. Have you ruled out the assumption?

See also