Empty Rectangle

Difficulty Tricky

In an Empty Rectangle, all the places for one digit in a box lie along two arms of a cross. A pair outside the box can force one arm to supply the digit and rule it out in another cell.

Find the two arms inside a box

Choose a digit in a box. Look for a row and a column that cover all its candidates in the box. Both arms must have a candidate away from their crossing.

The four box cells outside those arms form the empty rectangle. The digit can still be a candidate where the arms cross.

Outside the box, find a line with only two places for the digit. One end must see a whole arm. If that end is true, the box needs the other arm.

Look for a candidate that sees the far end and every place on the other arm. Either choice in the line rules it out.

Removals in the other direction

You can start from either arm. If the target and far end form another two-place line, trace it back for a second removal. A box with just two possible places can also form a short X-Chain.

Examples

Example 1

Example 1 ready.

In box 5, 9 can go only on row 4 or column 6. Placing 9 in R4C2 rules it out in R4C5 and R4C6 along the arrow.

If R8C2 is 9, R8C6 loses it. If R4C2 is 9, box 5 needs its 9 in column 6. That line also rules out 9 in R8C6.

Remove 9 from R8C6.

Strong link. At least one is true.

Trainer

Difficulty Tricky

Walkthrough

Use Pencil mode to remove a candidate.

See also

Some example positions come from HoDoKu regression library.