Following a chain

Difficulty Very Hard foundation

A chain follows what one candidate implies about the next. It can show that at least one of two distant candidates is true. Anything that conflicts with both can then be ruled out.

Read a chain from one end

Find a strong link between two candidates. From its far end, look for a weak link to another candidate that has a strong link.

One forced step at a time

Call the four candidates A, B, C, and D. The example connects them in this order with a strong link, a weak link, and a strong link.

Trace four possible 5s

1 / 6

Rows 1 and 4 each have only two places for 5. The diagram shows the 5s used in the proof.

Read the four ends

(5)r1c1=(5)r1c5-(5)r4c5=(5)r4c2

A is R1C1, B is R1C5, C is R4C5, and D is R4C2. The path reads A = B - C = D.

A blue ring marks a candidate in the pattern.An amber ring marks a second group.A solid line is a strong link. At least one end is true.A dashed line is a weak link. At most one end is true.An arrow points from an assumption to what follows.A red strike marks a candidate to remove.
What follows if A is false
StepReasonResult
A to BStrong linkB is true.
B to CWeak linkC is false.
C to DStrong linkD is true.

Suppose A is false. The links force B true, C false, and D true. Either A is true or D must be true. You can remove any candidate that conflicts with both.

The two ends can both be true. A chain like this only rules out the case where both are false.

Colors record a relationship

Two colors can mark opposite choices along links where exactly one end is true. A weak link alone permits both ends to be false, so it cannot establish opposite colors.

Check your understanding

1 of 3
One end of a link is false. Which type of link can force the other end true?

See also